Phil Collins: I Don’t Look Like a Sex God

Steve Turner, Radio Times, 31 March 1990

By his own admission Phil Collins is an unlikely superstar. He’s the drummer turned singer, the background boy become celebrity, the chap next door gone to Hollywood.

“I don’t look like most sex gods,” he cheerfully admits. “On my last tour I accumulated some amazing descriptions in reviews: stocky, balding, chubby, stout, urchin, elf, gnome! But I would never feel comfortable wiggling my bottom and dressing up in poncy clothes.”

None of it was planned. He started singing on his wife’s suggestion and only reluctantly fronted Genesis when Peter Gabriel suddenly quit. The songwriting, first displayed on Face Value (1981), was his response to a painful divorce and at the time Collins never intended it for public consumption.

“That event pushed me into writing,” he says. “Then someone suggested I put my home-studio recording out as an album. That’s when it all started happening, but it wasn’t as though I had decided it was time to do a solo album.

“If my missus hadn’t left me I suppose I would have done a jazz album instead,” muses Collins. “And that would probably have been the last you would have heard of me!”

In Radio 1’s new series beginning this Saturday, The Compleat Collins, Mike Read prompts him to talk his way through his career from the days as a drummer in a grammar-school band through Genesis, his solo recordings, his production work and his recent success as a film actor in Buster.

For the five-part series Collins has provided, his own, previously unheard, demos of his hit songs, as well as a private tape of Genesis. As the series shows, Collins is something of a workaholic – a member of Genesis since 1970, an active worker for the Prince’s Trust, as well as producer and actor.

To those who believe that rock’n’roll should be eternally youthful, angry and unintelligible to adults, Phil Collins represents all that has gone wrong. He’s Surrey-dwelling 39-year-old husband and father with an unthreatening demeanour, performing music that executives can pop into their CD players with no risk to their blood pressure. Mums and dads love him and he’s a favourite at Kensington Palace.

“I went through a period where I apologised for being nice,” he says. “But now I say what’s wrong with being a decent human being? I don’t particularly want to go around hitting people just to make me appear like everyone else.”

His most recent songs, released on the album …But Seriously, show him in a pensive mood, concerned about social issues and the responsibilities of parenthood as well as mulling over regrets about his own past insensitivity.

“My dad died eighteen years ago and I regret that I don’t have as many memories of him as I would like to have,” he says of the song ‘All Of My Life’.

“Sometimes I write because things like this are bothering me, but at other times the songs just creep up behind me and write themselves. ‘Another Day In Paradise’wrote itself. I didn’t have to sit down and say, ‘Let’s write a song about the homeless.’ I sat down at the piano, started singing and those words came out.”

Collins doesn’t analyse the market conditions that have facilitated his success. But, as he’s asked the question so often, he has thought about why the songs of an ordinary man from Surrey should have captured the imagination of so many …But Seriously is the fastest-selling album ever in Britain, where it has sold 1.7 million copies. But he’s not just a hit at home. He has reached number one in 22 countries.

“The only thing I can come up with,” he says, “is that I am a straight-ahead bloke. Very simple if you like. I think people relate to that. Judging by the letters I get it’s the lyrics that reach them.

“I write about people, not just relationships. I write about the way we treat each other whether it be in Northern Ireland or in South Africa. I write as a man in the street. Not as the man in the street, but as the normal person I am. I think that touches a nerve.”

[AWH – pop for the rest of us]

If a survey was considered into favourite in-car listening, Phil Collins would be sure to rank high. But who does the man himself listen to when he’s driving?

“At the moment it’s Phil Collins,” he laughs. “It’s my only chance to listen to rehearsal tapes, because when I get home to the baby and ‘real life’ there’s no time.”

He does find time, however, for cult Scottish band the Blue Nile: “I listen to both their albums. A Walk Across The Rooftops [1983]and Hats [1989], both of which I love – particularly Hats,” he says.

“I still listen to 60s records like With The Beatles, a lot of soul music and Tamla Motown. I don’t live in the past but I don’t get much chance to keep up with the latest stuff. I think Lisa Stansfield has a great voice. But mainly I’m listening to my music – because I have to!”

Phil Collins: Genesis Of A Solo Career

Chris Salewicz, Creem, January 1982

SET IN THE STOCKBROKER belt 30 miles to the southwest of London, the Genesis studio complex is exactly what you might expect: several thatched, suitably idyllic, wood-beamed 17th century buildings that until recently comprised a farm, with the studio itself housed in a modern, factory-assembled former cow-shed hidden by the high barn.

At the end of a sunny, late summer day I sit in the garden by a Shakespearian-like leafy cloister on a set of elegantly worn stone steps with Phil Collins, the Genesis drumming and singing workaholic who this year has enjoyed a large worldwide success with his first solo album, Face Value.

Phil’s slight physique and the cut of his thinning hair provide him with a profile at times disconcertingly similar to that of Brian Eno.

In fact, he says, it was working with Eno on his Another Green World album that considerably loosened him up as a musician, altering his attitude towards Genesis: “It showed me that anything could work. We did three days of just blowing. I learnt that you could do something at home, and it didn’t have to sound good – that it was the idea that counted. The logical extension of that was for me to do something at home that did sound good and feel good.”

Ostensibly we are here to consider Abacab, the latest LP by Genesis, a group that I cannot claim to considerably love, largely because the pleasant pop structures that lie at the heart of much of its material have for most of its career been buried in a pretentious, tumescent, musical overkill.

By contrast, Face Value is a loose, open work, strongly influenced by the drummer’s love of black music. Obviously it is significant that Abacab appears more closely related to the Collins solo record than to previous Genesis work.

In answer to the obvious question as to whether he would consider quitting the group, Phil is adamant in his denial.

“As far as I’m concerned,” he insists, “what I do on my own is not a solo career – it’s just one part of me. I’m my own man, and I chose to do a lot of different things. One of those things that I chose to do is still be in a group – Genesis.

“Also, I chose to do lots of different things with other musicians, because that keeps me fresh.

“So I would never leave the band. I see it as such a small part of what I do, anyway. It’s not as though I’m suddenly getting a chance to jack off on my own. I’m on my own already, and I put my energies to Genesis when the time comes round.

“However, I do think that Abacab is a definite step forward in terms of Genesis. By saying that I guess I’m denouncing what we’ve done already, though without meaning to sound as though I’m saying that.

“I’m just proud, though, that we’re thinking more…modern.” Phil admits that keyboardsman Tony Banks and bassist/ guitarist Mike Rutherford are far more willing to accept his idea since the success of Face Value.

However, he claims, the reason the Genesis sound significantly has shifted on this new record is down to their having produced it entirely themselves, in their own new studio – the first music they’ve so made. When he made his own album, which seems as much the cause for the shift in the Genesis sound, he rebelled very much against what he’d been taught was the grammar of studio recording, he explains. And such an attitude was sustained into the work on Abacab.

“We did things like use limiting to excess so that it would really be noticed. We really exaggerated a lot of things.

“I urge people,” he insists, “to forget what they think of as Genesis. There is definitely much more immediacy on this record, which I think is us getting better at writing and not clouding it up with shit. We shied away from stock Genesis devices such as sustained keyboards, and just honed everything down to its barest essentials. A lot of the songs are very, very unlike Genesis.

“We had one track which had the working title, ‘Fast Bass’, which we went ahead and recorded. And on tracks we’d already done like ‘Abacab’, and also for my own record, nothing flash and fast had been done, but just the right thing for the right song:

“But we started thundering along on this ‘Fast Bass’ tune, and suddenly we all stopped. We said, ‘This is what people expect to hear from Genesis.’ So therefore none of us felt frustrated that no matter how hard you tried it always ended up approximately par for the course. But my reason for staying in the group was that I always believed that eventually we would get there. And as far as I’m concerned I want to keep the group going until we get it right. And we never have really done it right.

“But Abacab is the rightest we’ve ever been.

“In fact,” he adds, “we’re totally unlike all those bands that have synthesizers and lights. Recently I did a Radio One Pop Quiz with Dave Gilmour, and he was exactly what I hoped he wouldn’t be. Also, though I really like Jon Anderson as a person, I completely hate that Yes kind of music.

“So it’s a double insult to be compared with stuff that I really can’t stand.”

[AWH- He’s bitchy himself.]

For long in England, much of the criticism of Genesis has been that the group is the perfect embodiment of “Public School Rock”: the English public school system so-called because it is open to anyone – anyone whose parents have the means to pay for it, that is. The smug side of Genesis’s music often has seemed derived on a direct conduit from the self-cherishing, uptight, elitism of that educational set-up.

Both Banks and Rutherford, as well as former members Peter Gabriel and Steve Hackett, all attended the relatively exclusive Charterhouse School.

Surprisingly, Phil Collins goes all the way in endorsing these criticisms of the group’s educational past at which at one time I recall Peter Gabriel bridling irritably.

“For a long time within the group,” he says, “the main problem has been that public school thing. I think it creates an odd feeling within you where you daren’t let go: You daren’t take off your clothes and live.”

Though both the other two Genesis members recently have put out solo records, they met far less success than Face Value. Phil says he received no resentment from them, though.

“There was nothing like that at all. Though Mike said,” he laughs, “‘I’m jealous.’…They view it, I guess, from the point of view that people who liked my album but didn’t like Genesis might give a Genesis album another listen now.

“Mind you,” he continues, “though Tony and Mike might have written more of the material, onstage it was me who linked that material to the audience. They had no personality onstage, and I had. So therefore who’s to say what it is that makes it a success.

“But we’ve always been very equal in the band. Cliched and unfashionable as it may be, we are a democracy. We work very well as a three-piece band because we all know each other’s strengths and weaknesses.

“Since the success of my thing, though, I know when I’m right and when I’m wrong. So I think it’s happening at the right time.”

Another landmark in Phil Collins’ career has just occurred with the release of John Martyn’s new album, Glorious Fool. The record, on which Phil also plays drums, is the first he ever has produced for another artist.

He became good friends with this exceptional Scotsman, says Phil, some three years back when both their marriages suddenly disintegrated.

Indeed, it was Phil’s split with his wife that inspired many of the Face Value songs.

“I came back from tour in 1978 to find my marriage gone,” he shrugs his shoulders in an attempt at being philosophical “We can talk to each other nowadays, which we never really did while we were married. Which was probably why we had to get divorced.

“That was a reason why Peter left the group, in fact: his marriage was in bad shape.

“You can’t really expect someone to understand why you have to be responsible to three other people. You can’t say to them, ‘Oh, I don’t want to go on this tour because I’ve got to do this instead,’ when they’re going to have to do the same thing next year. And it depends on the lady you’re mated with whether she can adjust to that. And my wife couldn’t.

“Now I’m with a lady who gives me much space as I need.

“But it’s an odd situation to get into. We were too much alike, I guess, and we’d end up at each other’s throats. Which was bad for our two kids, of course.

“But now we can always hang up on each other,” he laughs sadly, “whereas before it was never like that.”

© Chris Salewicz, 1982